Judge rejects HMRC bid to see expat’s private court papers

Crafty tax investigators are trying to unlock confidential divorce court documents to pursue a claim for unpaid tax against an expat husband who handed over a £48 million settlement in the UK’s most expensive marriage break up.

A legal challenge from HM Revenue & Customs to breach the confidentiality of proceedings in the High Court was thrown out by a judge.

HMRC launched the legal action in support of a claim for £11.5 million in unpaid tax against John Charman, who left the UK to live in Bermuda around six years ago.

HMRC says claims by Charman’s wife over his net worth relating to property and investments.

Following the claims and settlement, HMRC reassessed Mr Charman’s tax liability and presented him with the bill, which he disputes. HMRC want to use the court documents to prove their case, but Charman objects and the judge agreed with him.

Mr Justice Coleridge said: There was “no suggestion that the husband is guilty of tax evasion or criminal conduct in relation to his tax affairs”

“For the purposes of the tax appeal and that hearing HMRC would like sight of and to be able to use transcripts of the divorce/financial proceedings and many other documents which were filed in or brought into being for the application/hearing in front of me.

“They have asked the husband and the wife to produce them. The wife is not objecting but the husband has refused to do so and so HMRC have issued this application for their production.”

The judge said that evidence produced in financial remedy proceedings are not disclosable to third parties except in exceptional circumstances and by leave of the court.

“Having considered and balanced the competing public interests here, I have no hesitation in finding that there is nothing rare or exceptional about this case which takes it outside the general rule,,” said the judge.

“The husband is entitled to say, with indignation, that he complied fully with the rules of disclosure and the confidentiality/privilege attached to the documents and other evidence produced thereby should not be breached.”

Stay Connected

Latest News

HMRC Explained

HMRC is short for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs. The HMRC collects the taxes and customs duties that the British government spends...

Difference Between Residence and Domicile

For British expats, their residence and domicile determine how much tax they are likely to pay, both in the country where they...

QROPS, Qualifying Recognised Overseas Pension Scheme

QROPS is a type of pensions that were designed to cater for the needs of British pension holders that move out of...

Where Do British Expats Live?

More than 5.5 million people from Britain live overseas and leave the country at a rate of around 2,000 a week.

Living In The Philippines, A Guide for Expats

Brilliant weather, a low cost of living and friendly, English speaking people makes The Philippines a popular destination for British expats.

Living in Dubai, A Guide for Expats

Living in Dubai is the dream for thousands of expats enjoying a luxury lifestyle, high salary and a no tax income.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here