Retirement savers paid reduced benefits from company pension schemes rescued by the government may receive more money if the European Court of Justice agrees with arguments made by lawyers.
The Pension Protection Fund picks up failed company pension schemes and guarantees to maintain benefits for those already receiving them but pays 90% of the expected benefit to new pensioners.
High earners also have a benefits cap – currently £35,000 – regardless of how much money they were expecting from their retirement savings.
However, one British pensioner, Grenville Hampshire, has complained that the annual benefit cap is unfair on higher earners with larger pension pots.
The case has progressed to the final stages at the European Courts of Justice.
Legal challenge
Advocate General Juliane Kokott, who has taken up Hampshire’s case, said every employee in Europe is entitled to at least 50% of their entitlement to a pension if their employer goes to the wall and the pension is picked up by the Pension Protection Fund.
Hampshire started his legal challenge after his expected annual pension was slashed by 67% following the insolvency of Turner & Newall, formerly a manufacturing business, when the plan was transferred to the PPF.
Pension experts are expecting the court to side with the assessment which could have far-reaching financial implications for pension rescue funds across the European Union.
Anna Rogers, senior partner at ARC Pensions Law in the UK, explained rescued pensions would still likely be capped but at a higher rate than now.
Unfair cap
“The Advocate General has said that it isn’t fair that the PPF compensation caps ‘establish a kind of general suspicion in respect of senior executives who have not yet attained the pension age… a general presumption of the existence of abuse is unlawful’.”
The PPF says they are watching the case ‘with interest’.
“Members are currently receiving benefits from the Turner & Newall scheme at the levels set out in the Pensions Act,” a spokesman said.
“They can be reassured that this is the minimum that they will continue to receive.”
Some EU countries, such as The Netherlands, have no government rescue fund, and ruling for Hampshire could mean that they will have to establish one.
The ruling is not expected before August 2018.
